An Original Pittsburgh Pizza Play and Musical - Slice Something Slice


There I am starting the pizza show!

I wrote a pizza play called Slice Something Slice. Some call it a pizza opera or pizza musical. It’s a stage event about the power of pizza. I put the show on a few months ago with friends and family. It was so much fun we’re doing it again this October 29th at the Brillobox, but this time we’re opening this up to the pizza community at large. Tickets are on sale and we’re selling them at a nice clip. At only $10 (no fees!!) it’s a great deal for a truly unique experience.

Buy Tickets to the Pizza Play


What makes this Pittsburgh Pizza Play so unique?

The actors are you - well if you want!

There are six scenes in the play, each focusing on a different pizza parlor that the protagonist, Slice, visits. As people show up to the show they sign up for a part in the scene. You’ll be handed a script, a name tag and then when it’s your turn you’ll get on stage and read your lines.

Maybe you could be the Pizza Angel??

Maybe you could be the Pizza Angel??

Something truly magical happens when people get on stage. Obviously the script is very funny, but because we’re all in this together it becomes a safe space where the inner actor comes out. I was blown away by the performances last time we did this and I’m looking forward to seeing how everyone interprets these characters.

The scenes are short - maybe 5 minutes - so you’re not stuck on stage for long. You can see a list of some of the characters here.

There’s a live band playing original songs written for the play!

My friend and creative collaborator, Chad, got his band together and wrote a number of songs for the show. They help set the vibe and fill in some of the story beats. Like a real musical! If you ever heard the Pizza Talk With Me theme (below) you’ll love the songs at the show. Once you hear the Greasaroni Stomp, you’ll never forget it!

Pizza Play Theme Song
Chad McMutrie

I’m obviously bias, but having a live band on the stage just elevates the whole experience. Really makes it feel like a legit performance - which it of course is!

There’s a neat visual element

My sister made a nice little animation that, uh, expresses the themes of the show. It’s embedded below. Imagine seeing this on a big screen though - pretty cool!



Get your ticket today

The Story So Far

Here’s the Synopsis:

The story takes place on the Pizza Continent. Over time the citizens have cultivated the land to reflect the beauty of pizza. All citizens of the land love and enjoy pizza pretty much daily. There is an organization who operate a Pizza Priory.

This Priory takes in young children and trains them in the ways of pizza - this is important to their mission of uniting the world under one perfect pizza. They are protected from the outside world, but when the world needs united a Pizza Prophetis sent on a Pizza Pilgrimage to unite the land. These Pizza Prophets make their way to the Pizza Altar and give the ultimate pizza recommendation to the Pizza Angel.

Pizza Shops around the continent must obey the decree from the Pizza Prophet. The hope is that the prophet suggests the perfect pizza and everyone on the continent is united by the one perfect pizza. Yet, none have been successful.

Can the newest Pizza Prophet succeed where others have failed? Or will they be thwarted by the dreadful Greasaronis who haunt the prophets?

Part of the reason I chose to write about pizza is the silly little thing everyone does about pizza: argue about what’s the best. There’s frequently new rankings, pizza awards or pizza brackets in the media. Why? People can’t get enough. If you ever need a spike in web traffic put out a ranking of Pittsburgh pizza shops. Like throwing chum in the water.

This is shaping up to be a very special night, so text your group chat the link to the ticket page and start figuring out what parts you want to sign up for.

Two greasy guys playing the roles of GREASARONI TONI and Greasaroni Sam


Pizza Talk With Me Episode 13: Pizzeria Davide in the Strip District

Delicious pizza for all your summer outings

Delicious pizza for all your summer outings

Pizzeria Davide: Pizza Talk With Me Episode 13
Christa Cardone & Dan Tallarico

In this episode we declare Pizzeria Davide the official pizza of the Dogs Day of Summer. This is an elusive prize for pizzerias because eating a hot slice of pizza on a sweltering day may be overwhelming. But because Pizzeria Davide uses such fresh, delicious, ingredients their pizza is instantly refreshing. I could blend this up and drink it like a pizza smoothie!

Our Order

  • Pizzeria Davide Old World Style Pizza

  • The Lebanon Sweet Bologna & Hot Pepper Relish Pizza

  • The house salad

  • A secret meatball dish!

Pizza News

  • The Best Pizza City in America is Portland, Oregon - We can’t go one episode without discussing a list anointing a new city the pizza capitol of the world. This week we discuss how Nathan Myhrvold and Francisco Migoya ate their away through a handful of cities to decide the best pizza city. They of course missed out on Pittsburgh, but that’s okay, because I already documented the next generation of Pittsburgh Pizza in my Guidebook.

  • East End Brewing Opens Up Permanent In-House Pizzeria, East End Chewing - East End Brewing has been a staple in the Pittsburgh beverage scene since I can remember. They are always celebrating every aspect of the city in unique ways. Ways that don’t seem pandering, they love the city with such earnestness. They’ve been experimenting with serving pizzas throughout the pandemic and have decided to make the move permanent. Much like their series of beers for each Pittsburgh neighborhood, it sounds like each week they’ll have a new pizza for a specific Pittsburgh neighborhood. Excited to drink the Bloomfield Pizza with an Italian Pilsner!

  • Chuck E Cheese Frozen Pizza Arrives in Krogers Across the Country - Take the rate’s pizza home with you! It even has tickets in it!

Questions We Answer

  • What is the best cold one to have with a pizza?

  • Can dogs eat pizza?

  • What is the opposite of pizza?

  • When are we doing a Sir Pizza episode?

  • and more!

Join the Pizza Walk With Me Discord to talk about all things pizza with your new pizza besties!

Listen on Apple Podcasts

Listen on Spotify

Listen on Google Podcasts

Find your pizza date with Pizza Date With Me

Pizza Talk With Me Episode 12: Caliente Brooklyn Pizza

Caliente Brooklyn Pizza
Pizza Talk With Me Episode 12
Christa Cardone & Dan Tallarico

It was only a matter of time before we would bump into local pizza heroes, Caliente. Maybe you’ve seen their billboards along 376 East heading into the city? About five miles out from the Liberty Tunnels is a billboard explaining that Caliente Pizza & Drafthouse is a multi-Pizza Championship winning pizza parlor. We of course broke the story of their first victory back in 2016 where they premiered the Quack Attack.

Caliente has wasted no time in expanding their pizza empire across the Pittsburgh area. As I write this, Caliente is working on opening a new story in Sewickley (in the old Sharp Edge) which will be their sixth location.

Their menu is vast. Clearly not sticking to any specific guidelines their mantra seems to be “develop the best, most interesting pizza on earth.” So far they’ve been awarded with enough accolades to fill up a few billboards.

On this week’s episode, Christa and I sample a sliver of the Caliente menu. We bite into their absurdly large Brooklyn pizza (which requires a custom box!) and their garden salad. Does it pass the crunch with your munch test?

We also get in touch with a real life Brooklander to give us the deal on Brooklyn pizza.